10/11/2004

on the bald Muslima

the following text is inspired by a short article in the newspaper.

A few weeks ago I read in the newspaper that a French girl had shaven all her hair off, to be allowed to go to school. In France, high-school pupils are no longer allowed to attend school while wearing a veil or other prominent religious signs. The girl’s mother declared that her daughter believed that showing her hair was against her religion. The girl wanted desperately to attend school and to her this was the only way to stay faithful to her beliefs and be allowed to attend school.



Why do Islamic women go hidden under their veil and is going bald an acceptable alternative? I am not a Muslim, so I do not know why those women wear a veil. I sometimes wonder whether they really know it themselves, or simply do it, because other (older) people told them to do so. The Islam religion does not allow people to criticise the Islam. The Qur’an is perfect, and whoever questions the book, or Allah, is a sinner.
However, I know the Qur’an prescribes women to cover their chest, and believe this is interpreted as ‘to cover their hair (and chest).’ As I understand it, the goal of the veil is to hide the beauty of the woman. This beauty will turn the heads of men, who cannot contain their lust. Women are therefore bad creatures, who try to lure the men away from the right path. And men are sexual beasts, who stop thinking straight the moment they see a woman. Since we cannot change the nature of men, the Islam wants to hide the beauty of women, and punishes them for their beauty. All women that show their hair and skin (other than face and hands) are therefore hores.
In this context, I do not think going bald has the same effect as hiding one’s hair. It is not just the hair that makes a woman beautiful and attractive. And it is not just hair that arouses lust. I find bare skin much more sexual than hair.
Though most men will not find a bald woman attractive, there are some very beautiful bald ladies. And there are probably some men that will only fall for bald women.

Finally I wondered whether strangers would now consider her to be a skinhead, with all prejudice that goes along with this entitlement. The following French Forum has a picture of her.

The last thing I would like to say is that I find this girl very courageous and hope that a lot of girls will follow her example. I hope Muslim men will show their compassion and shave their heads as well. I would applaud it if bald would become the trend, because it would eliminate all differences.
Though shaving her hair could have been an act of despair, it also strikes me as an act of protest. I see it as a protest against this discriminating law (even though there are good intentions behind it), which does not allow freedom of expressing one's religion, and as a protest against the rigid nature of her own religion, which does not allow a lot of things which are normal for Western people.

After having read an article in which the attitude of Dutch and French people towards the Islam is considered, I came to the conclusion that the people in these countries have totally different perspectives. It is therefore unlikely that I share the view of the French, or that they share mine. I do not know the exact reasoning of this girl, or her motives to shave off her hair.

She is probably just a girl that tries to be faithful to herself (her own culture and religion) and to the Law of the French Democracy. She proves herself a French citizen with dignity.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

For someone who says she does not know anything about why I wear a hijab, you do go on so:)
I will answer your questions because you seem like a good enough kid.
- We cover as its states specifically in the hadith (books that detail the teachings of the prophet) and is also generally referred to in the Quran.
-No one should force someone to cover their hair. No one should force someone to uncover their hair.
-We are Muslims (One who submit to the will of Allah). Islam means peace. We are also referred to as the believers. We do not doubt our faith, God, or our prophet.
-We hear the command of Allah and we obey.
-In Islam the power of choice is huge. There is no compulsion in religion, meaning people need to choose the path for themselves it cannot and should not be imposed by people.
-That girl in France refused to have her will subverted by the governments oppressive laws. She has guts. Anyone who believes in freedom should understand where she is coming from.

Hi, I'm Cheryl, a geochemist with an interest for sustainable development. said...

Thank you for your reaction!
As I am not a religious person I look at the world and people's actions with very different eyes than religious fellow(wo)men.
Freedom is for me the greatest gift.
I consider your reaction as a beautiful example of how religion should be celebrated: without compulsiveness, and out of free will.